gsustek wrote:stas2z wrote:build000 wrote:3) Do the authors/producers of the original firmware/device are planning any factual support in the main line openwrt ?
Witi stock firmware is a bit changed mtk sdk openwrt released by Mediatek in their 4.x SDK. Mediatek is not going to support mainline. Their BB based "firmware" is a 3.10.x MTI kernel with hwnat hack + proprietary wifi drivers which are not opensource. It was a marketing trick and experiment which failed in the 4.3.x.x sdk. SDK 5.0 kernel have no openwrt hooks and im sure current mtksdk openwrt (from 4.3) is a last. Also the mediatek 3.10 kernel is an experiment, "stable" kernel for the Mediatek SDK based firmwares is 2.6.36 (which used by ~100% of vendors for ralink/mediatek socs).
If this is true, the witi openwrt mainline support for this device is just a light version of what this device trully can do.
Does someone maintain this version of source for witi ,or maybe with even more feature which mtk SDK/SoC offers?
I have tested performance of original WiTi FW with MT Wi-Fi drivers and HW NAT and my conclusion was that it brings no real performance improvement vs. OpenWRT trunk. Both have problems with WiFi transfer speed in both 2.4GHz and 5GHz bands. I have compared WiTi running original WiTi FW with MT drivers with and without HW NAT, OpenWrt CC and OpenWrt DD trunk with TP-Link N750 router running original proprietary FW and WiTi has significantly lower performance with any FW :-( In fact my results showed that the best performing WiTi FW was trunk but the differences are small. On top of that WiTi does not provide reliable performance all the time. There is big variation of WiFi transfer speed during the test and also the teste results vary a lot while TP-Link provides always the same and good performance.
BTW: For me the biggest issue of WiTi is SAMBA/NFT throughput on WiFi. While on cable connection I have roughly 28MB/s write speed, on 2.4GHz wifi it is only 800kB/s :-( I have tried both NFS and Samba. NFS is slightly better but still < 1MB/s. I tried the same with TP-Link that has USB2 drive connected and I have ~2MB/s write speed. Considering that WiTi has fast SATA drive connected the results is very disapointing.
(Last edited by KejPi on 8 Jan 2016, 15:54)